Gee, what a future: A response to James Gee’s talk

A more detailed summary of James Gee's lecture can be found in the companion piece titled: Problems in education, as solved by James Paul Gee


As a student, it’s incredibly distressing to hear James Gee speak about the future of the traditional university system. Thousands of colleges are going to fail over the next few years. The typical university will face threats from all sides that will test their embedded inertia against change. From the bottom, for-profit institutions like University of Phoenix will take care of those who are just looking for a piece of paper and some letters after their name.  For those who are unwilling to sacrifice prestige, the big-name brands are offering online programs, like MIT-X. There is also a rising movement of proponents for a credential-based system; degrees are a vague measure of accomplishment and, because of grade inflation, the face-value merit of a university diploma is distressingly diminished. The system needs to change and few academics would bet on any radical shift happening soon. Higher education is falling prey to the same deficiencies as the K-12 school system: teaching the wrong stuff in a woefully outdated context, with insufficient standards. Heck of a time to be seeking a degree.

Futurism is a heady brew

Gamification of an existing system is pragmatic—it is a copy/paste from games onto existing real-world systems, yielding optimized results with minimal effort. Building “serious games” goes one step further, in that it is an original production arising from the explicit purpose of merging games and reality. These efforts have gained a lot of traction (or caused a bunch of hype, depending on who you talk to), and it’s going to take a lot of work before the average citizen sees this as a viable model for societal systems. Then comes Gee—and he takes it as far as fact and reason might allow, all the way to society becoming a ludic, fluid, intuitive, pragmatic collective of knowledge builders. After the talk, my head was swimming. Hearing about the future from one of the “gamer greats” is always a foundation-shaking experience. Games as immersive introductions into fields of knowledge, as a sort of embodied initiation into paradigm-shifting affinity spaces… it’s a lot to wrap one’s head around. Gee should be praised for this initial conception; I can’t wait to see what comes from this. In the meantime, like most talks that have inspired me, I have so many questions! The three main agents seem to be games, society, and education and so I will try to address each in turn.

Games

Collective intelligence, as a concept unto itself, seems to have very little to do with most gaming. Intelligence is a thing; gaming is a system, a process. Game systems can increase intelligence, but Gee says that games are a playful primer for learning, not the heart of future knowledge. The idea is that games will teach an embodied understanding of basic principles, encouraging further exploration of the subject matter. In the talk, he references Portal as an example of a “Game,” which has two main effects:

1)       In the “lower-case” game, players can learn some basic physics via embodied learning; acting out the conservation of momentum really does embed the concept in a unique way.

2)      Then, players are theoretically primed to learn basic physics lessons.  They will, if sufficiently interested, explore wikis, learn more complicated applications, and become contributors to the Portal-physics affinity space.

Sure, but only to a point—right?

Learning is more than just doing something, or even doing that something a thousand times: learning is what happens when the concrete becomes abstract. Specific lessons must become general rules, otherwise we wouldn’t be able to apply information from one context in another. Gee acknowledges that, eventually, people must stop and read a few terms; the game manual comes later, it’s not that it doesn’t come at all. Eventually, there is still a bunch of (online) reading one must do to go from enthusiast, to contributor to collective intelligence. Thriving in an affinity space might feel pretty game-like, and getting into one through a video game is obviously a gaming experience—but after that first session of games, what exactly is supposed to happen next? The moment-to-moment learning seems strikingly devoid of any game-based design. Right now, the formula looks something like this:

  1. Play a video game. Have fun, pick up basic concept through embodied learning.
  2. Go the forums, wikis, and other sites that compose that game/concept’s “affinity space.” Revel in the community, pick and choose subjects for fun and loosely read up on stuff.
  3. Adopt a few spaces and get to work! Read when necessary, but ask the community first. Craft whenever possible, always iterate. Tinker, experiment.  Slowly but surely, master things.
  4.  Congratulations—you are now an important contributor to the affinity space! Continue to research and commune. Be prepared to work with other masters to determine and maintain standards for conduct and quality.

The first step sounds like fun, but the rest sounds like a career trajectory, optimistically described. Nothing is causing all this work to be fun; Gee presumes it will be fun because it’s supposed to be voluntary. That’s not a bad start, except that most work is NOT something we’d volunteer to do—that’s why it’s work.  It’s a question that’s been asked—and mostly unanswered—as we continue to apply games to other aspects of life: can work become play? Gee didn’t directly address this question and it’s possible to glean different perspectives:

  • Yes, work can become play. The intent of the model is to make the subject immediately interested by playing a video game and gaining “embodied experience”—then, pouring through forum posts and learning coding becomes an extension of that initial experience. So, even though things become more difficult and less rewarding (fewer breakthroughs, less frequently) than the video game, it’s all still rooted in that ludic framework.
  • No, work and play are fundamentally different. Find your interest in play, then move forward into work. Affinity spaces resemble games in some ways—for instance, they both involve voluntary participation, intrinsic motivation, egalitarianism, and community feedback—but not others. Games are neatly packaged, solvable puzzles involving abstractions of real systems, but affinity spaces ARE real systems. Real-world problem solving often isn’t as clean; sometimes, it’s not even possible. Games are fun to figure out because there’s no uncertainty about the fact that they can be figured out. A lot of motivation is lost when the outcome is unclear. (Furthermore, any potential for immediate feedback is lost whenever there is no experience-oriented design. If someone’s path isn’t set out before them, it’s nigh impossible to know when, where, and how to reward them. Community feedback is nice, but it’s necessarily post-hoc and is not the moment-to-moment feedback most modern gamers have come to expect. )

Regardless of which side you agree with, one fact remains: there is no designed experience when people go to learn in affinity spaces. While some avid fans might create this or that module, there is no authoritative structure demanding a flow from one piece of user-created content to another. People might make one-off “lessons,” but it is up to the individual to create their own “curriculum.” Granted, games like Minecraft also lack purposeful progression; we call them sandbox games—but those titles are games in name only. You play with Legos, you don’t “play Legos.”

So, with this lack of experiential design and the large swath of uncertainty between the first and last steps, here is the impression I got:

  1. Play a video game.
  2. Go online.
  3. Look at stuff, ask questions.
  4. Try things, get feedback.
  5. Repeat 3 and 4
  6. ???
  7. ???
  8. ???

…

97. ???

98. ???

99. Become a self-selected contributor to collective intelligence.

How likely is it that players will take that leap? The analogy of games and manuals only goes so far. Let’s face it: Portal is fun and it does teach some physics, but nobody could pass even the most basic physics test by playing through either Portal game, or even both. Played a hundred times with commentary and an online guide that talks you through what principles your actions indicate, you still would only learn… what, four things? Five? Gameplay does part the job, but there’s a big gap between playing Portal and writing in a science journal. And, as a motivator, how far does the essence of the game really carry a person? It’s not like everyone who played with toy dinosaurs became a paleontologist, or anyone with a cap gun joined the police force because they played “cops and robbers” as a child. It is one thing to say that games provide a playful introduction to some mildly complex topics, but it’s quite another to say that “playing a video game” is anywhere near a significant predictor of deeper exploration or skill acquirement through online affinity spaces.

The Portal series has sold millions of copies, but I doubt that more than a few hundred people have gone further than merely finishing the game. And, of those relatively few who made it a capital-G “Game,” most made some computer wallpaper or a Companion Cube tote bag. Even if some Portal players are future winners of the Nobel Prize in Physics, correlation isn’t causation. Seriously, it won’t be long before some future genius cites 2007 (the year Portal debuted) as the year in their childhood that ‘changed everything’ and placed them on the path to scientific achievement. That I do not doubt. However, I have to question the likelihood that a video game is itself enough to set someone down a career path, that it would give them enough background and/or motivation to take the leap from player to scholar.

Society

The types of affinity spaces that Gee described—with the focus, complexity, and agency of an institutional force—do not yet exist. Except, perhaps, for a couple of burgeoning exceptions (like Wikipedia), no online community is even ready to begin competing on that level. Logically, that’s either because it hasn’t happened yet, or because it will not happen. Affinity spaces have to be natural, which limits how fast and efficiently they can grow. At the moment, it can only be said that they have not grown enough—but it is too early to determine how far they can go. The greatest strength of affinity spaces is also the greatest roadblock toward the model reaching the critical mass it will need to supplant other existent systems.

If they weren’t natural—as in “not forced,” or intrinsically motivating—they wouldn’t attract people. If it was mandatory, it would be work; the exact same behavior can be either work or play—that’s why voluntary participation is key. A compulsory system based on affinity spaces would be a different form of what we have now, but would still based on the fundamental mentality of “suck it up and do it, anyway.” Since they must be natural, they will evolve organically. Without any “intelligent design,” there will be plenty of redundant organs and inefficient processes. People who participate in a forum discussion might experience a truly enlightening flow of information, but the system doesn’t help initiates into the fold. Currently, entering an online community is a messy affair. Board posts become buried in threads and links to external content can fall into disrepair. Foraging for nuggets of knowledge makes people more devoted archeologist than casual searcher—the way things are “organized” on the internet makes it work to look up information… to do work that’s already thinly framed as play.

In addition to form, there’s also the matter of content—specifically, subject matter and ownership.

Any space where large amounts of people gather with common purpose is something to be celebrated. But what do affinity spaces coalesce around? Sure we can celebrate them—but what are they celebrating? Well, for one thing, yes: education. The limitless supply of how-to videos on YouTube and the clutter of responses in Yahoo! Answers are more than sufficient as face-value proof. To offer a bit more depth, though: as I learned in my first Informatics class this semester, plenty of stats junkies find cool new ways to display large datasets. They learn programming and valuable interpretive skills.

Some good things for which you can find an affinity space:

  • Curing diseases: Go help researching protein structures by playing FoldIt or, if you’re busy, just select Folding@Home on your Playstation to donate processing power. (Pro tip: Look inside the portal called “Life with Playstation.” It’s okay, I couldn’t find it at first, either.)
  • Standing up for people’s rights:  Affecting real-world change during the Arab Spring and controlling virtual bullying in Second Life—both within the purview of affinity spaces (check out the work of the group “The Wrong Hands” if you’re interested in the latter).
  • Sharing knowledge: Wikipedia = best site ever. Free in every sense of the word, somewhere between peer-reviewed journal article and a half-baked science paper some fourth-grader put on their GeoCities page a decade and a half ago, the Wiki format lends itself well to the affinity space concept.

Many affinity spaces, though, are for geeky fandom—and most are not advancing the species in any meaningful way. You’re likely reading this in a web browser right now. When you leave this page, where are you off to next? Curing any diseases with your “new tab” button? Ten to one, your next online social interaction will involve something far more mundane, like reviewing your last purchase or posting in the comments section of an article—because everyone needs to know that you’re glad the newest Spider-Man sticks to canon with homebrew web-shooters (pun intended). Most of our online social interactions are vapid, more opinion-spewing than fact-building; they are also perpetrated on top-down corporate sites, not grassroots affinity spaces.

The internet was seen as a potentially great equalizing force but, increasingly, media scholars have resigned themselves to the reality that “legacy platforms”—sites built by pre-internet media corporations, like CNN.com—will create a familiar, safe, glossy and relatively homogenized upper crust of the internet. The vastness of the Web will (hopefully) remain, but the average user will chat on Facebook, shop on Amazon, and watch videos on YouTube.

“Imagine no possessions,” John Lennon offered, “it’s easy if you try.” We live in a world where the very concept of socialization is more or less Zuckerberg’s plaything. Sorry, John, but it’s just not happening.

So, who will own affinity spaces? I hope they appreciate the irony of their Midas touch.

Education

Teaching nothing but abstractions and obtuse, manual-like lessons is a travesty and it needs to change—but lest we forget, that is not what traditional education is really supposed to be about. There is an essential part of learning that will be inadvertently discarded if we abandon classrooms for forums and fan sites. Perhaps more significantly, ditching the classic model will still not remove Gee’s biggest complaint about the foundering education system: its “content fetish.”For all the railing against “content,” it cannot be avoided. A medium contains a message; a space is filled with stuff. By definition, a field or subject is already full or writing that explicates concepts, details methods, and offers opinions—and we consider these things a part of the body of knowledge.

Reading is important. Literature gives people common-ground terms. If we didn’t have that, we would be coining terms and reinventing language with every publication; we wouldn’t be able to communicate—not effectively, at least. Existent content also obviously lets us know what came before, what doesn’t need reinventing. Pragmatically, reading—or “content” in general—is where people actually learn. People must spend time with reading material, with collected knowledge. Not everything can be taught experientially; one of the most beautiful things about the human brain is its ability to imagine so much more than what we get through sensory experience. Words are annoyingly abstract, but that impediment is, in reality, a great strength. When we learn language, we learn so much. Abstraction of concepts helps us generalize, to compare things and balance them in complex mental networks. Scroll back up and look at my confused model of progress in affinity spaces. Many of the steps between 5 and 99 will unquestionably involve reading content. Affinity spaces may change who writes the manual and when/how people refer to them… but there will always, always be a manual.

Pedagogy is important, too. Ted Castronova, expert on virtual economies, is nothing if not a believer in the power of online spaces. However, “some knowledge you have to talk to people about,” he says, “and that’s the magic you won’t get in an affinity space.” The “magic” Castronova refers to might not be essential for learning how to program, but it’s vital for a field like anthropology. In his talk, Gee treats all knowledge as homogenous—but it’s not! “A market-based logic of education,” Gee said, “encourages students to focus on its instrumental value—that is, as a credential—and to ignore its academic meaning and moral character.” Vocational training is one thing, but scholarship is quite another. It’s not enough to know what someone thought or observed; as my graduate director might say, there is a “texture” to learning in a university system that is inextricable from a proper graduate-level education. It’s not just about the stories, but the way they are told that can really flesh out things. In fact, I would go so far as to say that, for more scholarly subjects, reading books and sitting in a classroom IS embodied learning; “academic meaning” is the experiential framework college students use to recall what they learn. Academia could never become a full-fledged affinity space because it needs those intonations during lectures, the chance meetings in the hallway. Education as a holistic concept seems to violate the rules of an affinity space, which exclude interpersonal connection as a primary goal. A complete education needs personality, not just people.

Even if we don’t need professors in person, even if the classroom is an outmoded method of knowledge transference, it can’t be acceptable to leave people to their own whims.

  • Motivation: Think back to when you were growing up—if you didn’t have a spelling test every week, would you have read a list of vocabulary words? Didn’t think so. Even with things we enjoy, some stages of learning are more enjoyable than others. There will always be a point between “novice” and “expert” where something is not intrinsically enjoyable; that’s when we need an external system to frame things and keep us motivated. Games are built on this principle.
  • Efficiency: As mentioned earlier, the internet is a heaping mess of user-generated content. Even if you can eventually find what you’re looking for, isn’t it great when somebody organizes things for you? That’s not a cop-out, that’s deference to intelligence and experience. I know of people who sign up for classes just to get the reading list. Furthermore, the do-it-yourself mentality only fares worse when it comes time to absorb and implement the material. Not everyone can learn by reading and tinkering on their own; not everything can be taught that way, either.
  • Equality: What kind of society results from this? On principle, we all want egalitarianism and achievement-based reward. It’s only fair. However, the truth is that some people achieve more than others—and leaving learning up to individual pseudo-students is just going to widen the gap. Societal rebalancing might occur, and it may be based on fair moral principle, but it will still be disproportionate. In a way, this system is more brutally Darwinian than what we have now.

Despite my critiques, I still think the concept is fascinating. It is one logical extension of what is being talked about in the large conversation about “games and society,” and it is important that we consider where fads and trends might lead. What if game-like systems permeate the core of our societal structure? We can’t advocate for changing “the system” unless we’re willing to offer a solid suggestion for what should assume its place. We also have a responsibility to make sure it won’t repeat old issues, or create unsolvable new ones. That all begins with outlining large-scale models, like Gee’s affinity spaces, and continues when we talk about those models. Please, continue the discussion.

Gee, what a future: A response to James Gee’s talk by Kenneth Rosenberg, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

52 Responses to “Gee, what a future: A response to James Gee’s talk”

  1. golden goose says:

    I definitely wanted to write a quick remark so as to appreciate you for the magnificent instructions you are showing on this site. My time-consuming internet lookup has at the end been rewarded with beneficial facts to exchange with my best friends. I 'd repeat that many of us site visitors are definitely lucky to be in a wonderful place with many perfect people with beneficial hints. I feel rather privileged to have discovered your site and look forward to some more enjoyable moments reading here. Thanks again for all the details.

  2. off white says:

    I would like to convey my admiration for your kindness giving support to visitors who absolutely need assistance with this idea. Your very own commitment to passing the solution all around became extraordinarily invaluable and has regularly allowed others much like me to reach their desired goals. Your warm and friendly information can mean so much a person like me and extremely more to my peers. Regards; from everyone of us.

  3. kyrie shoes says:

    Needed to compose you that tiny word to help say thanks a lot yet again about the fantastic information you've featured above. It is certainly remarkably generous with people like you to present easily just what a number of people might have sold for an ebook to generate some profit for their own end, particularly since you might well have done it if you ever considered necessary. Those basics also worked to provide a easy way to be sure that most people have similar dreams the same as my personal own to see a little more in terms of this condition. I think there are thousands of more pleasant sessions up front for individuals that read carefully your site.

  4. I in addition to my friends happened to be looking through the best procedures from your website and so the sudden I had an awful feeling I never thanked you for those techniques. The ladies happened to be certainly joyful to read through all of them and have in reality been taking advantage of these things. Thank you for genuinely simply thoughtful and for utilizing this kind of fantastic resources most people are really desirous to discover. My personal honest regret for not expressing appreciation to earlier.

  5. Code Herb says:

    In my opinion you are not right. I suggest it to discuss. Write to me in PM, we will talk.

  6. I truly wanted to construct a simple message so as to thank you for all of the splendid hints you are giving out on this site. My long internet investigation has at the end been recognized with reasonable details to share with my pals. I would declare that many of us website visitors actually are truly fortunate to dwell in a very good website with so many brilliant people with beneficial solutions. I feel really privileged to have encountered your entire webpage and look forward to some more cool minutes reading here. Thanks once again for a lot of things.

  7. kyrie shoes says:

    I would like to show my appreciation for your kindness for those individuals that need guidance on this study. Your personal commitment to getting the solution all-around ended up being wonderfully productive and have constantly enabled others just like me to reach their endeavors. Your amazing warm and helpful suggestions means a lot a person like me and somewhat more to my colleagues. Best wishes; from everyone of us.

  8. I would like to express my thanks to this writer just for rescuing me from this issue. Just after surfing throughout the internet and meeting tricks that were not pleasant, I assumed my life was well over. Being alive devoid of the strategies to the difficulties you've sorted out by means of the report is a crucial case, and those that would have badly damaged my entire career if I hadn't encountered your blog. Your own ability and kindness in maneuvering every item was precious. I don't know what I would have done if I hadn't discovered such a point like this. I can also at this point relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for the professional and amazing guide. I will not hesitate to suggest the website to any person who requires counselling on this subject matter.

  9. I happen to be commenting to make you be aware of of the outstanding encounter my friend's princess obtained viewing your blog. She discovered plenty of issues, not to mention what it is like to possess an ideal teaching mindset to get most people without hassle have an understanding of specific advanced matters. You actually surpassed her desires. I appreciate you for displaying these valuable, trustworthy, informative and fun thoughts on the topic to Tanya.

  10. Quite right! Idea excellent, I support.

  11. kd shoes says:

    I really wanted to post a word to thank you for some of the superb tricks you are posting at this site. My time consuming internet search has now been rewarded with beneficial strategies to exchange with my good friends. I would repeat that many of us website visitors are quite blessed to exist in a remarkable site with very many marvellous people with valuable tips. I feel rather lucky to have discovered your web site and look forward to some more pleasurable minutes reading here. Thanks once again for a lot of things.

  12. jordan shoes says:

    I wish to show my thanks to this writer just for rescuing me from this challenge. Because of searching through the the net and coming across methods which were not pleasant, I was thinking my life was well over. Living without the presence of answers to the difficulties you've solved as a result of your guideline is a serious case, and the ones that might have in a negative way affected my career if I hadn't come across your web page. Your actual know-how and kindness in handling almost everything was tremendous. I'm not sure what I would have done if I hadn't come across such a point like this. I'm able to at this point look forward to my future. Thanks for your time very much for your high quality and effective guide. I will not be reluctant to recommend your site to anyone who would need recommendations about this issue.

  13. Thanks a lot for giving everyone an extremely terrific chance to read critical reviews from this site. It's always very pleasant and packed with a great time for me and my office fellow workers to search your site particularly 3 times every week to see the newest guidance you have. Not to mention, I'm usually happy concerning the excellent concepts you give. Selected 2 ideas in this article are honestly the very best I have ever had.

  14. jordan retro says:

    I am writing to make you understand of the superb discovery my daughter obtained visiting your web site. She mastered lots of issues, most notably what it's like to have a marvelous helping mindset to make other people really easily understand a number of specialized subject matter. You truly surpassed my expected results. Thanks for displaying these essential, dependable, edifying and even cool tips about that topic to Tanya.

  15. Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an exceptionally memorable possiblity to read from this blog. It is often very superb plus packed with a lot of fun for me and my office co-workers to visit your website at a minimum thrice weekly to find out the fresh guidance you will have. And lastly, we are at all times motivated considering the effective methods you give. Some 2 tips in this article are rather the most efficient I've had.

  16. yeezy supply says:

    I as well as my buddies ended up taking note of the excellent hints located on the website while all of the sudden came up with an awful feeling I had not expressed respect to you for them. These people became consequently thrilled to read through them and have simply been having fun with them. Many thanks for simply being quite helpful and also for selecting these kinds of notable issues most people are really desperate to be informed on. Our own honest apologies for not expressing appreciation to you sooner.

  17. I truly wanted to type a brief word in order to appreciate you for some of the lovely guidelines you are sharing at this website. My time-consuming internet search has at the end been compensated with wonderful facts to exchange with my company. I would assume that we site visitors actually are very blessed to be in a great website with so many brilliant people with very helpful pointers. I feel very much fortunate to have discovered your entire website and look forward to tons of more brilliant moments reading here. Thank you once again for all the details.

  18. I enjoy you because of each of your efforts on this blog. My mom really loves getting into investigations and it is simple to grasp why. Almost all notice all of the powerful method you deliver functional guides on this web blog and improve participation from other individuals about this point while my princess is undoubtedly studying so much. Have fun with the remaining portion of the year. You are performing a really great job.

  19. goyard store says:

    I have to express thanks to this writer for bailing me out of this particular matter. After browsing throughout the the net and getting recommendations that were not pleasant, I was thinking my life was gone. Existing minus the solutions to the issues you've solved all through your entire report is a serious case, and the ones which might have badly affected my career if I hadn't come across your site. That ability and kindness in maneuvering a lot of things was very helpful. I'm not sure what I would've done if I hadn't come across such a stuff like this. I am able to at this time relish my future. Thanks very much for this reliable and result oriented guide. I won't think twice to recommend your blog to any individual who should get support on this subject.

  20. I want to get across my gratitude for your kindness in support of people who must have help on this one subject matter. Your personal commitment to passing the solution all-around appears to be wonderfully interesting and have consistently enabled many people just like me to realize their goals. Your entire useful advice signifies much a person like me and even further to my office workers. Thank you; from everyone of us.

  21. I simply wished to thank you very much once more. I am not sure the things I might have used without the type of ways revealed by you concerning such a topic. It actually was a daunting case in my view, but discovering the very professional form you handled that made me to jump over happiness. I'm just happy for this guidance and even pray you find out what a great job you were doing instructing some other people with the aid of your site. I know that you haven't encountered all of us.

  22. hermes says:

    I needed to compose you the little bit of note so as to give many thanks again just for the gorgeous techniques you've featured in this article. It's really unbelievably generous of people like you to present unreservedly all that a lot of people could possibly have offered for sale as an e book to make some profit on their own, and in particular considering the fact that you could have tried it if you ever wanted. The tricks additionally worked to provide a easy way to know that other people have similar desire really like my personal own to know the truth many more pertaining to this condition. I think there are a lot more fun occasions ahead for those who discover your website.

  23. Thanks a lot for giving everyone such a terrific possiblity to read in detail from this site. It's usually very awesome and packed with a good time for me and my office fellow workers to visit the blog not less than three times per week to find out the fresh secrets you have got. And of course, I'm so actually contented considering the attractive thoughts you give. Some 3 ideas in this post are basically the most beneficial I've ever had.

  24. curry shoes says:

    I am only writing to make you be aware of what a remarkable discovery our princess developed visiting your site. She came to understand some issues, most notably what it's like to have an awesome helping spirit to get folks with no trouble know precisely specified complex issues. You actually exceeded our own desires. Many thanks for producing the valuable, safe, educational and in addition easy thoughts on this topic to Evelyn.

  25. air jordan says:

    I not to mention my friends have been taking note of the nice advice located on your web site while quickly got a horrible feeling I never thanked the web blog owner for those secrets. Most of the young men are already for this reason excited to see all of them and now have simply been taking pleasure in those things. Appreciate your really being considerably considerate and then for considering this sort of good subject areas most people are really desperate to discover. Our own honest regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.

  26. off white says:

    Needed to send you this bit of word so as to say thank you again considering the amazing guidelines you've shared on this website. This has been certainly incredibly generous of people like you to convey without restraint what a few people would've sold as an e-book to help with making some bucks on their own, especially considering the fact that you could possibly have done it if you ever desired. Those advice in addition worked like the easy way to recognize that someone else have the identical dream like my own to know many more with regard to this matter. I think there are numerous more pleasant occasions in the future for individuals that find out your site.

  27. ggdb says:

    I wanted to create you that little bit of observation just to thank you once again for the stunning guidelines you have shown at this time. It has been quite unbelievably open-handed with you to supply publicly what many individuals would've sold for an electronic book to make some dough on their own, particularly seeing that you could possibly have done it if you considered necessary. The basics likewise worked like the fantastic way to understand that other people online have similar eagerness like my own to find out significantly more with reference to this issue. I'm sure there are some more pleasurable opportunities up front for folks who read carefully your blog post.

  28. curry 6 says:

    I enjoy you because of all your valuable efforts on this website. Debby take interest in working on research and it is obvious why. A number of us notice all concerning the compelling method you make very important secrets by means of the web blog and even improve contribution from visitors on that concept while our favorite simple princess is actually discovering a whole lot. Enjoy the remaining portion of the year. You're carrying out a good job.

  29. kd 15 says:

    I'm just writing to make you understand of the magnificent experience my cousin's daughter obtained viewing your web site. She figured out a wide variety of pieces, with the inclusion of what it is like to have an awesome helping heart to have many more without hassle completely grasp specified tortuous subject matter. You actually surpassed our expectations. Thanks for delivering the effective, trustworthy, educational and also fun tips on your topic to Janet.

  30. supreme says:

    I together with my guys were digesting the good suggestions from your web blog and then developed a horrible suspicion I never expressed respect to the site owner for those tips. All the men are already for that reason joyful to read through them and now have extremely been tapping into these things. Appreciation for turning out to be very considerate as well as for figuring out these kinds of high-quality useful guides most people are really wanting to know about. My very own honest regret for not saying thanks to sooner.

  31. you've got an important blog right here! would you prefer to make some invite posts on my weblog?

  32. I am constantly browsing online for ideas that can facilitate me. Thx!

  33. I wish to show thanks to this writer just for bailing me out of such a scenario. As a result of surfing through the world-wide-web and obtaining concepts that were not powerful, I thought my life was over. Being alive without the approaches to the problems you've sorted out through the guide is a crucial case, as well as the kind which may have in a negative way affected my entire career if I had not encountered your blog. Your capability and kindness in dealing with every aspect was invaluable. I am not sure what I would've done if I hadn't come upon such a subject like this. I can also at this moment relish my future. Thanks a lot very much for the professional and results-oriented guide. I will not think twice to refer the sites to any person who requires assistance about this subject matter.

  34. jordan shoes says:

    My husband and i got now joyful when Jordan could deal with his preliminary research using the precious recommendations he gained while using the web pages. It is now and again perplexing to just always be freely giving concepts the rest may have been trying to sell. And we also acknowledge we need the writer to be grateful to because of that. The entire illustrations you've made, the straightforward website menu, the relationships you will aid to instill - it's many astonishing, and it's really facilitating our son and our family imagine that this situation is excellent, and that's particularly vital. Thanks for everything!

  35. jordan 11 says:

    I wish to show my appreciation to the writer just for bailing me out of this particular difficulty. After researching throughout the online world and coming across concepts that were not beneficial, I thought my entire life was over. Living devoid of the solutions to the problems you have resolved through the guideline is a critical case, as well as ones which might have in a negative way affected my entire career if I had not come across your web blog. Your actual knowledge and kindness in controlling a lot of things was excellent. I am not sure what I would've done if I had not discovered such a thing like this. I can also now look ahead to my future. Thanks a lot very much for your impressive and sensible guide. I will not hesitate to recommend the blog to any person who would need support about this topic.

  36. goyard says:

    I together with my guys happened to be following the excellent key points found on your web site and quickly got a horrible feeling I never thanked the web blog owner for those tips. My young boys were certainly glad to learn them and have now in actuality been using these things. Many thanks for truly being indeed kind and also for making a choice on variety of superb themes most people are really eager to learn about. My personal sincere regret for not saying thanks to sooner.

  37. Thanks so much for providing individuals with remarkably remarkable possiblity to discover important secrets from here. It really is very beneficial and as well , stuffed with amusement for me personally and my office acquaintances to visit your site at the least 3 times in one week to see the latest issues you have. And of course, I am at all times amazed with the gorgeous concepts served by you. Certain 4 ideas on this page are without a doubt the most efficient we have all had.

  38. kd 12 says:

    I precisely desired to thank you very much once again. I am not sure the things that I would've done in the absence of the points provided by you regarding such industry. Entirely was a difficult setting in my position, however , discovering the well-written form you resolved that forced me to weep over delight. I will be thankful for your support and thus wish you are aware of an amazing job you are always carrying out instructing many people via your website. I'm certain you have never met all of us.

  39. I precisely needed to appreciate you yet again. I'm not certain the things that I could possibly have done without the entire suggestions shown by you directly on such concern. This has been a real intimidating situation in my position, however , considering a new well-written fashion you managed that took me to weep for happiness. I am happier for this help as well as expect you find out what a great job you're getting into instructing men and women all through your blog post. Most probably you've never got to know all of us.

  40. goyard says:

    I have to voice my love for your kindness giving support to persons that really need guidance on in this situation. Your special dedication to passing the solution throughout was quite interesting and have always encouraged somebody just like me to attain their pursuits. Your personal interesting recommendations implies a great deal a person like me and still more to my fellow workers. With thanks; from each one of us.

  41. I precisely wished to thank you very much all over again. I'm not certain what I would've used without the entire tips shown by you on such a problem. It became the hard matter in my opinion, but coming across this expert approach you dealt with it forced me to weep over gladness. Now i'm happy for the help and in addition pray you find out what a great job that you are putting in instructing many others through your blog. Most likely you have never got to know all of us.

  42. ggdb says:

    I simply wanted to thank you so much once more. I'm not certain the things that I could possibly have tried in the absence of the type of recommendations documented by you about such a theme. This has been a real depressing difficulty in my position, nevertheless being able to view a professional form you resolved it took me to weep over fulfillment. Extremely happier for the assistance and as well , expect you realize what a great job you were undertaking training the others via your site. I know that you have never encountered all of us.

  43. bape says:

    Thank you for every one of your hard work on this blog. My mom takes pleasure in setting aside time for research and it's simple to grasp why. A lot of people notice all of the dynamic mode you render helpful tips by means of your blog and therefore attract response from other ones on the concept so our own girl is without a doubt discovering so much. Enjoy the rest of the new year. You are always doing a fabulous job.

  44. I not to mention my pals were actually looking through the great thoughts from your web site while all of the sudden I got a terrible feeling I had not thanked the web blog owner for those secrets. All of the young men were for that reason joyful to see them and have now absolutely been taking pleasure in those things. Thank you for turning out to be quite kind and then for making a decision on variety of helpful tips most people are really desperate to learn about. Our honest apologies for not expressing gratitude to you earlier.

  45. I would like to express my thanks to this writer for rescuing me from this type of challenge. Because of checking through the search engines and meeting tricks that were not helpful, I assumed my entire life was gone. Being alive minus the strategies to the problems you have sorted out by means of this guide is a critical case, as well as the kind that would have negatively affected my career if I hadn't encountered your website. The mastery and kindness in playing with all areas was invaluable. I don't know what I would've done if I hadn't discovered such a point like this. I can now look forward to my future. Thanks a lot so much for this high quality and sensible help. I won't hesitate to suggest your blog to anyone who should have counselling on this matter.

  46. Thank you so much for providing individuals with an exceptionally breathtaking opportunity to read critical reviews from this blog. It's usually so terrific and also packed with amusement for me and my office fellow workers to visit your website not less than 3 times weekly to read the fresh guides you will have. And indeed, we're usually fascinated with your tremendous suggestions you give. Certain 2 tips in this posting are absolutely the most impressive we've ever had.

  47. I'm just commenting to make you understand what a exceptional experience our girl undergone visiting your site. She came to understand plenty of details, which include what it's like to have an awesome helping heart to get most people really easily learn a number of tortuous subject areas. You really surpassed people's desires. Many thanks for imparting such warm and friendly, dependable, informative and also cool guidance on this topic to Tanya.

  48. My spouse and i felt very delighted that Chris managed to carry out his analysis via the ideas he discovered from your own web site. It is now and again perplexing to simply happen to be giving out methods that many many people might have been making money from. And now we remember we need the website owner to be grateful to for that. The entire explanations you made, the easy site navigation, the relationships your site aid to promote - it is most extraordinary, and it is leading our son and the family consider that this content is awesome, which is unbelievably serious. Thanks for the whole lot!

  49. golden goose says:

    My wife and i ended up being quite delighted that Emmanuel managed to finish off his web research with the ideas he gained when using the web site. It's not at all simplistic to just choose to be giving away tips many others have been selling. And we see we now have the writer to give thanks to for this. The main illustrations you have made, the easy website navigation, the relationships you can give support to engender - it is most superb, and it's making our son in addition to the family believe that this subject matter is amusing, which is unbelievably serious. Thanks for all the pieces!

  50. off white says:

    I simply wanted to say thanks once more. I am not sure the things that I would have done without the type of solutions shown by you concerning my theme. It was the traumatic dilemma in my opinion, but taking note of a specialised strategy you treated that forced me to jump for happiness. Now i'm grateful for the service and hope that you comprehend what a great job your are carrying out teaching other individuals thru your site. Most probably you haven't got to know any of us.

  51. yeezy says:

    I precisely had to thank you so much once again. I am not sure the things that I might have tried in the absence of those tips contributed by you over that subject matter. This was a real alarming circumstance for me, however , taking note of the specialized technique you solved it made me to jump over delight. I'm just happier for the assistance and as well , sincerely hope you really know what a powerful job you are putting in training many people with the aid of your webpage. I know that you haven't got to know any of us.

  52. I as well as my pals came analyzing the nice tips found on the website and all of a sudden developed a terrible suspicion I never thanked you for those strategies. My men ended up as a result stimulated to read them and have unquestionably been taking advantage of those things. Appreciation for indeed being simply helpful as well as for obtaining some very good ideas most people are really desirous to know about. My sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to you earlier.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Problems in education, as solved by James Paul Gee | Motivate. Play. - [...] organic, and open. Read about his argument below, then visit this story’s companion piece – Gee, what a future …
  2. Free MMORPG 2022 - Free MMORPG 2022 Skidson is the best free to play fantasy MMORPG based on AQW

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>