Intrinsic/extrinsic motivation: A false dichotomy?

The Joy of Mining

The impact of Deci & Ryan’s self-determination theory in social psychology is difficult to overstate. This is the source of the frequently argued point that intrinsic motivation (motivation to do something based on inherent properties of the task that make it interesting or enjoyable) is undermined by extrinsic rewards (i.e., points, money, badges, etc.). The theory is not universally accepted: Extrinsic rewards offered for performing boring tasks have been demonstrated to lead to greater intrinsic motivation, and two (controversial) meta-analyses have argued that rewards that reflect competence increase inherent interest in a task. Chris Heckler has sorted through the literature to illuminate the two points on which most researchers seem to agree:

For interesting tasks,

  1. Expected, tangible rewards that are contingent on task completion (generally) reduce free-choice intrinsic motivation, and
  2. Verbal, unexpected, informational feedback (generally) increases free-choice and self-reported intrinsic motivation.

Let’s focus on the first point. Why is this true? Some argue that it’s because we tell ourselves stories about why we do what we do: when rewards are present, our story is more likely to become “because I’ll get a reward” than “because I want to.” Others say it’s because we feel that we are being cajoled or bribed, which causes us to devalue the task—if someone has to reward us for doing it, it must not be worth doing on its own. In either case, it is our beliefs about the inherent value of the task that drive intrinsic motivation. The danger in both cases is that when the rewards are removed or become uninteresting, our motivation for the task will vanish as well.

However, things get complicated in the case of games, in which some tangible, expected, contingent rewards also happen to make a game more inherently interesting or enjoyable. Furthermore, rewards that are extrinsic to one aspect of a game can provide intrinsic motivation for another, often in an indirect or unpredictable way. A thought experiment from Jesse Schell’s 2010 Gamasutra interview illustrates how easily things can get hairy:

"But this is where it gets tricky -- is that intrinsic and extrinsic are tangled in complicated ways. So, for example, I may set up a system of giving out points, right, that's totally extrinsic. And you would say, "Well, therefore, in the long run, it won't work."

Well, but what if me and my friends all kind of get into it, and like we start this kind of social thing about one-upping each other, and we're now doing it not because we care about the points for the sake of the points, but it now becomes like a little social ritual with us, which is intrinsically rewarding?

So, these extrinsic systems can sometimes become an anchor for something that has intrinsic power, and that part is where I think our brains get a little tangled up, because it's difficult to predict and it's difficult to plan for."

And another from Ted Castronova:

"If a man does not want to do a task, but does it in return for $10, we say that he was extrinsically motivated, but not intrinsically motivated. OK.

If the man plays a game and is not paid to do it, we say that he was intrinsically motivated. He "wanted" to.

Suppose a man is playing a game and does not want to perform a task, such as, mining. Yet if he mines ore and sells it in the game, he gets a thing called "gold pieces." So he performs the task. Is he intrinsically or extrinsically motivated? Which if any of the following are true?

1. The man is intrinsically motivated to play the game, since he wants to do it without any reward other than just playing the game.

2. The man is extrinsically motivated to play a part of the game, the mining.

3. The mining is nested inside the game. Thus you can have extrinsic motivations nested inside intrinsic motivations.

4. The man is motivated partly intrinsically and partly extrinsically to play the game.

Here's where it cuts. According to the theory, a game is more engaging if it is more intrinsically rewarding… These games could take out all the mechanics that use extrinsic motivation, all the grinding elements. It seems to me that that would be a pure candy environment, and boring."

The research on intrinsic motivation suggests that if the mining task is “interesting” (in the absence of reward), then receiving a reward is likely to make it seem more dull; if the mining task is dull, receiving a reward might make it seem more interesting, or it might not, depending on whose theory you subscribe to.

If we assume the mining task is dull, then fewer people are likely to put in the effort to perform it, making the resulting gold pieces objectively more valuable. Also, independent of the actual economics, self-perception theory suggests that the duller the task, the more valuable the reward will seem (I wouldn’t be swinging this heavy pick, the player tells herself, if I weren’t getting something totally awesome in return). I’m speculating here, but it doesn’t seem too implausible that having an in-game currency of high psychological value enables a more interesting economy, more difficult and compelling choices about how to allocate one’s resources, and other high-level phenomena that make the game inherently enjoyable. So here, as in Schell’s example, eliminating a mechanic that seems superficially extrinsic is likely to undercut an intrinsic motivator that supports the experience of playing the game as a whole.

If we can’t be sure about the effects of eliminating seemingly extrinsic motivators, a logical alternative strategy would be to amp up seemingly intrinsic ones. In the next post, I’ll talk about how multifaceted theories of motivation provide game designers with more actionable ways to do just that.

Intrinsic/extrinsic motivation: A false dichotomy? by Gabriel Recchia, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

19 Responses to “Intrinsic/extrinsic motivation: A false dichotomy?”

  1. kyrie 6 says:

    Thank you for all of the effort on this web page. Debby takes pleasure in engaging in internet research and it's simple to grasp why. A lot of people know all concerning the dynamic tactic you render both interesting and useful solutions through your web blog and in addition encourage participation from some other people on this matter while my child has always been becoming educated a lot. Take pleasure in the remaining portion of the year. You're performing a remarkable job.

  2. My wife and i got now relieved Albert managed to finish off his studies by way of the precious recommendations he discovered from your very own blog. It is now and again perplexing to just always be handing out methods which often the rest could have been making money from. And now we acknowledge we now have the website owner to be grateful to for this. Most of the illustrations you have made, the easy blog navigation, the relationships you make it easier to engender - it's got most superb, and it's helping our son and our family reckon that the subject is thrilling, which is extremely indispensable. Many thanks for all the pieces!

  3. golden goose says:

    I intended to send you this little bit of word to help say thanks once again on the pleasing information you have discussed on this website. It has been surprisingly generous with you to give freely exactly what a few individuals would've offered as an ebook to earn some dough on their own, certainly considering that you could possibly have done it in the event you wanted. These creative ideas likewise acted to provide a fantastic way to be certain that some people have the identical passion similar to my personal own to understand way more in respect of this matter. Certainly there are millions of more pleasant sessions in the future for people who browse through your blog post.

  4. I precisely wanted to thank you so much once more. I am not sure what I would've achieved in the absence of the type of opinions shown by you relating to such a question. It had been a alarming issue for me personally, but looking at this expert tactic you resolved it made me to leap with fulfillment. I'm happy for your guidance and as well , believe you find out what a powerful job you are putting in educating other individuals through a site. Probably you've never encountered all of us.

  5. birkin bag says:

    I am just writing to let you be aware of what a notable experience our child had studying your web site. She learned several things, most notably how it is like to have an excellent giving heart to have other folks effortlessly completely grasp a number of problematic matters. You undoubtedly exceeded her expected results. Many thanks for coming up with those priceless, trustworthy, edifying and in addition easy tips about this topic to Tanya.

  6. curry shoes says:

    I simply wished to appreciate you once more. I do not know the things I would've carried out in the absence of the actual techniques documented by you directly on my theme. It had been a real hard scenario for me personally, nevertheless coming across a skilled style you solved the issue took me to jump over joy. I'm happier for the help and then pray you are aware of a great job you happen to be accomplishing teaching the rest through the use of your web page. I know that you haven't come across all of us.

  7. kyrie 9 says:

    I needed to draft you one little bit of word so as to give many thanks over again for all the precious strategies you've shared on this website. It's certainly tremendously open-handed with people like you to deliver freely just what a lot of people would have advertised for an electronic book in order to make some profit for their own end, specifically considering the fact that you might well have done it if you ever desired. These strategies likewise worked to become a great way to know that someone else have the same keenness the same as my very own to find out somewhat more in respect of this condition. I'm certain there are lots of more fun periods up front for those who looked at your site.

  8. I simply wanted to send a word to appreciate you for all of the fantastic suggestions you are giving on this site. My particularly long internet research has finally been compensated with incredibly good know-how to share with my close friends. I 'd repeat that most of us website visitors actually are truly fortunate to live in a decent community with very many perfect individuals with good strategies. I feel pretty lucky to have seen the web site and look forward to some more fabulous minutes reading here. Thanks once more for all the details.

  9. Thank you a lot for giving everyone an exceptionally terrific opportunity to read in detail from here. It can be very excellent and as well , full of a great time for me personally and my office co-workers to search your website nearly thrice every week to read the fresh issues you will have. And definitely, I am certainly pleased considering the unique opinions you serve. Selected two areas in this post are in fact the simplest I have had.

  10. My husband and i got so thrilled that Jordan managed to deal with his studies through the ideas he acquired from your own weblog. It is now and again perplexing just to possibly be giving out helpful tips many people have been selling. We really understand we have the writer to thank for this. Those explanations you made, the straightforward website navigation, the friendships your site help to foster - it's got most great, and it is assisting our son in addition to our family reason why the content is satisfying, which is exceedingly mandatory. Thanks for all the pieces!

  11. I simply wanted to send a quick comment to appreciate you for those amazing points you are sharing at this website. My considerable internet look up has at the end of the day been paid with really good suggestions to write about with my contacts. I 'd say that we readers are undoubtedly fortunate to live in a great network with so many special people with great advice. I feel very much happy to have come across your web page and look forward to so many more excellent minutes reading here. Thanks once again for everything.

  12. I needed to compose you that very little remark to give thanks the moment again regarding the gorgeous knowledge you have discussed above. It has been simply surprisingly open-handed with people like you to supply unreservedly precisely what most people could have sold for an ebook to help with making some cash for their own end, most notably now that you might well have done it if you decided. The pointers additionally acted to become a easy way to know that many people have the identical dreams really like my own to see whole lot more concerning this matter. I'm certain there are some more fun situations up front for individuals who browse through your site.

  13. air jordan says:

    I am commenting to let you be aware of what a nice encounter our child gained reading through your web page. She realized such a lot of pieces, which included what it's like to possess an ideal teaching mood to let a number of people smoothly know just exactly a number of problematic subject matter. You really did more than visitors' expectations. Thank you for displaying the powerful, trustworthy, educational not to mention cool tips on your topic to Julie.

  14. I intended to put you a little note in order to thank you as before for your fantastic suggestions you have documented on this site. It has been so strangely open-handed of people like you to grant extensively all that many of us could possibly have offered for an e-book to help make some money for their own end, specifically considering the fact that you could have done it in case you desired. These principles additionally served to become a good way to fully grasp most people have the same zeal much like my own to find out many more with regards to this issue. I am sure there are lots of more fun times up front for those who scan through your website.

  15. Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an extraordinarily wonderful possiblity to discover important secrets from this website. It is often so pleasurable and as well , full of a good time for me personally and my office friends to search your web site the equivalent of three times in 7 days to read the newest tips you will have. Not to mention, I am just certainly fascinated with the awesome knowledge served by you. Certain 1 tips on this page are absolutely the most efficient we have ever had.

  16. I want to express some appreciation to the writer just for rescuing me from this particular trouble. After surfing through the world-wide-web and coming across advice that were not beneficial, I believed my life was over. Living without the presence of answers to the issues you've sorted out by way of your main review is a serious case, and those which could have in a negative way damaged my entire career if I hadn't come across your blog. Your own personal capability and kindness in dealing with all the pieces was important. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not come across such a point like this. I can at this moment look ahead to my future. Thanks a lot so much for this impressive and effective help. I won't hesitate to propose your web blog to anyone who wants and needs care on this subject.

  17. off white says:

    My spouse and i felt really more than happy that Peter could conclude his reports through the ideas he got from your own web page. It is now and again perplexing to simply choose to be making a gift of ideas that many the others could have been making money from. And we all do know we have the writer to give thanks to because of that. The type of illustrations you have made, the straightforward site menu, the friendships your site assist to foster - it is mostly terrific, and it is assisting our son and our family recognize that the subject is cool, and that's exceedingly important. Many thanks for the whole lot!

  18. I must show some thanks to this writer for bailing me out of this particular predicament. Just after exploring throughout the the web and finding views which were not productive, I thought my life was done. Being alive without the presence of approaches to the difficulties you have resolved as a result of this website is a serious case, and the kind that might have adversely damaged my entire career if I hadn't discovered your web page. Your primary talents and kindness in touching all the details was crucial. I don't know what I would have done if I hadn't encountered such a subject like this. It's possible to at this moment relish my future. Thanks for your time very much for this skilled and results-oriented guide. I won't hesitate to refer your blog post to anyone who should receive counselling on this problem.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>